The Cinnamon Spice Inn Review | Cozy Small Town Romance

It’s officially time for seasonal drinks and treats! As I sit down to write The Cinnamon Spice Inn review, I’m sipping on my first autumn drink of the season- a maple hazel latte from Costa. I’ve been craving an autumnal drink for a few days now, all thanks to a perfect first read for autumn- The Cinnamon Spice Inn by Harper Graham.

I was lucky to receive an advance reader copy of The Cinnamon Spice Inn from NetGalley and the publisher, Bookouture. This is Harper Graham’s debut novel, and let me tell you — if you love cozy, small-town romances full of warmth and second chances, this book is for you. Keep reading this spoiler-free The Cinnamon Spice Inn review to see why it deserves a spot on your fall TBR.

The Cinnamon Spice Inn on Kindle Unlimited. If you are already subscribed, then you can start reading now. If you’re not a member already, you can start a free trial here.

_{As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. I am also a Bookshop.org affiliate. This means I may earn a small commission if you click through and make a purchase—at no additional cost to you. I only share books and products I truly love, and all opinions are entirely my own.}

The Cinnamon Spice Inn by Harper Graham

Rating: 
Spice: 
Taylor Swift Songs That Vibes: ’tis the damn season — straight from the book’s own playlist, and it fits the nostalgic, small-town feels so well.
Tropes: second-chance, childhood best friends, forced proximity, small-town romance, miscommunication, mysterious letters
Favorite Quote: “I’d want this in any lifetime, in any world. Always you.”

What is The Cinnamon Spice Inn About?

The Cinnamon Spice Inn is a cozy small-town romance packed with autumn charm. Madison, a food critic living in New York City, is pulled back to her hometown of Maple Falls after receiving an anonymous letter urging her to help save her family’s inn. Since her mother’s passing, the inn has fallen into disrepair under the care of her father and grandmother. Determined to restore it to its former glory, Madison decides to close the inn for a few weeks, renovate, and reopen on Halloween.

But her plans take a turn when a storm knocks a tree into the inn, forcing her dad to call the town handyman — none other than Zach, her ex and childhood best friend. The storm also damages Zach’s own home, leaving him in need of a place to stay. The solution? He’ll live at the inn rent-free while helping Madison with the renovations.

With forced proximity, small-town meddling, and unresolved feelings, Madison and Zach can’t ignore the spark that never really went away. Still, old heartbreak lingers, and they must decide whether risking a second chance at love is worth it — or if some chapters are better left closed.

Why You’ll Love The Cinnamon Spice Inn

• Delicious seasonal treats — warm cinnamon rolls, homemade apple butter, and steaming drinks that will have you craving café runs and fall baking.
• Small-town charm — Maple Falls is filled with meddling neighbors, quirky locals, and that irresistible sense of community.
• Second-chance romance — Madison and Zach’s history makes their reunion feel tender, nostalgic, and full of spark.
• Festive autumn vibes — from cozy inn renovations to a big Halloween reopening, it’s brimming with seasonal atmosphere.
• Feel-good storytelling — Harper Graham’s debut blends heartwarming family themes with a swoony romance that feels like a Hallmark movie in book form.

What I Wished There Was More Of

The Cinnamon Spice Inn leans heavily on the miscommunication trope, which isn’t one of my personal favorites. While I loved Madison and Zach’s chemistry, I often found myself wishing they would sit down and talk things through sooner instead of letting misunderstandings drag on. A bit more direct communication between them would have made their second-chance romance even stronger.

Final Thoughts

Reading The Cinnamon Spice Inn felt like the perfect way to welcome autumn — cozy, comforting, and just a little bit sweet. Between the mouth-watering seasonal treats, the small-town charm of Maple Falls, and the second-chance romance at its heart, Harper Graham’s debut novel captured everything I love about fall reading.

While the miscommunication trope wasn’t my favorite, the overall warmth of the story and Madison and Zach’s journey still made this a delightful read. If you’re looking for a romance to pair with your favorite seasonal latte and a soft blanket, The Cinnamon Spice Inn is the perfect pick for your fall TBR.

Before You Go…

If cozy, small-town romances are your thing, then The Cinnamon Spice Inn definitely deserves a spot on your fall TBR. Don’t forget to grab your favorite seasonal drink before curling up with this one — cinnamon rolls optional, but highly recommended.

And if you’re on the hunt for even more seasonal reads, don’t miss my list of September 2025 Romance and Fantasy Book Releases You’ll Love.

And before you go, make sure you follow me on Pinterest and Instagram for more cozy reviews, swoony tropes, and all the romance recs your bookish heart could ever need.